How to Verify a Chinese Supplier Proforma Invoice Before Wiring a Deposit (Evidence Check, No Escrow Account Needed)

Most importers check a new Chinese supplier the same way: a video call, a look through the factory photos, maybe a search of the company name. Then a Proforma Invoice (PI) arrives, the deposit is due, and the bank details get a quick glance before the wire goes out. That last step is where many payment problems start. The company you checked and the account you pay are not always the same thing.

This guide covers an evidence check you can run on a PI before you send a deposit. It does not need an escrow account, a lawyer or special software. It needs the PI, the supplier's business registration details and an hour of careful comparison.

The short answer

Why the Proforma Invoice deserves its own check

The PI is the document that turns a negotiation into a payment. It names who you are paying, how much, for what and on what terms. Fraud and honest mistakes both tend to show up here, because this is where money moves. A supplier can run a genuine factory and still send a PI with a wrong account number, an account that belongs to a trading partner, or terms that differ from what you agreed.

Step 1: Match the issuer to the company you checked

Write down the supplier's full legal name exactly as it appears on its business registration. Chinese companies register a Chinese name and often use an English name that is only a translation, so ask the supplier for the registered name and its unified social credit code, an 18-character identifier.

Then compare three things, character by character:

  1. The issuer name and address on the PI.
  2. The company on the business registration.
  3. The beneficiary name in the bank details.

Small differences matter. "Shenzhen Example Packaging Co., Ltd." and "Shenzhen Example Trading Co., Ltd." are different companies. A PI issued by a trading company for a factory you visited is not wrong in itself, since many factories sell through a related trading arm, but you should know which entity you are contracting with and why.

Step 2: Look hard at offshore Hong Kong accounts

Many mainland suppliers take payment through a Hong Kong company or a Hong Kong bank account. There are ordinary reasons for this, including currency handling and older trading set-ups. It is also a common pattern in payment fraud, because a Hong Kong shell company is cheap to set up and its link to the factory can be hard to see.

When the beneficiary is a Hong Kong entity, ask:

If the answers are vague or keep changing, pause the payment.

Step 3: Treat changed bank beneficiaries as a stop signal

The most damaging pattern is a late change. You receive a PI with one set of bank details, then a follow-up email says the account has changed because of an audit, a tax issue or a new bank. Sometimes this is genuine. Often it is not: the supplier's email account may be compromised, or someone may be posing as the supplier.

Do not act on a bank change received by email alone. Confirm it by calling a phone number you already had on file, not one given in the new message. Ask for a revised PI on letterhead and compare it line by line with the first one. If anything other than the bank details has moved, ask why.

Step 4: Check the numbers against your landed cost

A PI can be genuine and still be a bad deal. Check unit prices, quantities, packing terms and the Incoterm against what you agreed. Then estimate your full landed cost: goods, freight, insurance, duty, inspection and import fees. The China landed cost and QC calculator puts these in one place. If the deposit is a large share of the landed cost before any goods have been inspected, ask whether the payment terms match the risk.

Step 5: Record your decision

Write a short note: what you checked, what you found, what you asked and the answers you received. Save it with the PI and the registration documents. If something goes wrong later, that record helps your bank, your insurer or your lawyer, and it makes the next supplier check faster.

When to ask for a second pair of eyes

If the checks above leave you unsure, ChinaPayCheck offers a stepped route that starts at no cost:

  1. Free Triage, 0 USD. One supplier, one Proforma Invoice, one payment decision. Send the case through the ChinaPayCheck contact page for a first read on whether the documents line up.
  2. Single-Case Pre-Payment Review, 49 USD. Offered only after a case has been accepted at Free Triage. The written review follows the format of the published sample case, EXAMPLE-CPC-001.
  3. Workspace plans. For buyers who check suppliers often, there is an online workspace: Free at 0 USD, Starter at 20 USD a month, Growth at 100 USD a month and Pro at 200 USD a month. You can cancel any time. Supplier goods and shipping are billed separately.

What ChinaPayCheck is and is not

ChinaPayCheck is an independent buyer-side evidence review and China sourcing agent. It is not a law firm, bank, escrow agent, insurer or recovery agency. It makes no promises about supplier safety, account ownership, product quality, shipment, recovery of funds or legal outcomes. What it gives you is a structured review of the evidence you share, so you can make your own payment decision with fewer blind spots.

It never asks for passwords, banking logins, card numbers, private keys or one-time codes. If anyone claiming to represent it asks for those, stop and report it.

FAQ

Is a Hong Kong bank account always a red flag?

No. It is common and often legitimate. It becomes a concern when the link between the Hong Kong company and the factory is not documented, or when the account appears late in the deal.

What if the supplier refuses to share registration details?

That is a useful answer in itself. A genuine business can usually share its registered name and unified social credit code. A refusal is a reason to slow down.

Can I skip these checks for a small first order?

A small order limits your loss, but the same patterns apply. Fraudsters often start with small, smooth orders to build trust before a larger one.

Does escrow remove the need for this check?

No. Escrow can hold funds, but it does not tell you whether the PI, the beneficiary and the company match. The evidence check is still yours to do.

Disclosure: I work with ChinaPayCheck, the buyer-side evidence review service linked in this guide.